On being American, part 1

DarthClem

Shared on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:11

"Para español oprima numero dos".  I hear it any time I call a customer service numer.

While watching football this weekend, I saw a commercial for Lowe's.  When the husband and wife walk into the kitchen department, the sign above them has written "Centro de la cocina" just below the English.

I was helping clean up a school in north Milwaukee recently as part of our company's community service day.  The signs in the hallway that said cell phones should be turned off were written in Spanish, not English.

I get a credit card bill and it's in English on one side and Spanish on the other.

We need to turn in the forms from my kids' school photos today.  The form was conveniently written in both English and Spanish.

I love Latin culture, the music, the food, the language, las chicas, etc.  One of my two best friends is Mexican.  When I go to a Mexican grocery store or restaurant (which is often), or when I'm in Latin America (which is not so often), I do my best to speak Spanish.  When I struggle, I apologize (in Spanish) and rather than just switching to speaking English, I ask for their help to learn the Spanish phrase I am attempting to say.  I feel that it is the way to show respect to their language and culture.

And yet, it kind of feels to me like our American culture is being invaded.  Now before you go and call me xenophobic and tell me that there is no "national language" in Los Estados Unidos, just hear me out.  When my ancestors came to this country, they wanted to become Americans.  There was a great deal of pride in that.  Of course they wanted to maintain their culture, but they also wanted to assimilate into American culture.  They were embarrassed if they couldn't speak English.

I love the cultural diversity that makes up this country -- the metaphorical "melting pot".  But when you melt something, it merges with the other things your are melting.  There seems to have been a shift in the last 100 years away from the idea of melting into a unified American identity/culture and toward something else that I'm struggling to name without referring to The Borg.  It's as if the ethnic identiy has taken precedence over the American identity and may even be attempting to usurp it..  I believe that part of the American identity is being able to speak the de facto language here -- English.  Because honestly, I think we're only a handful of years before English is the secondary, subtitled language that shows up on signs.

Comments

MikeJames's picture
Submitted by MikeJames on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:15
I agree 100%. My dad came over from Italy. He was told to only speak English in America. He did not teach me Italian (except some curse words) because we are in America and I need to know English. This is the way the old generation thought as they crossed our borders. MJ
RIGHT_WINGAMER's picture
Submitted by RIGHT_WINGAMER on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:17
Amen brother...AMEN!
Kyosogi's picture
Submitted by Kyosogi on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:17
Americans are consumers first, English speakers second. Check that... people in the U.S. are consumers first, English speakers second. It's about the U.S. dollar, not the U.S. (national) language.
MikeTheKnife's picture
Submitted by MikeTheKnife on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:21
As long as the chief language is english I don't think it's a problem, but if the english does become a subtitle then I think there'd be a problem. However if certain areas do become hispanic majority (as has been rumored to be coming for years)--then I don't really see what would be wrong in them voting spanish as a main language in those areas if it's done through the system, with legal voters, I really don't. Please don't revoke my 'conservative asshole' member's card.
ekattan's picture
Submitted by ekattan on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:22
Kyosogi has a very good point. But Clem is also right that the American Culture is being invaded. It has been so for years though. What about the St. Paty's Day?
English_C6H6's picture
Submitted by English_C6H6 on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:29
Yeah, well, a lot of the reason to speak English before was to be able to participate in the mainstream economy/social services. Now that the mainstream economy and social services have found it desirable (profitable) to go to consumers in their native language, the is less incentive to learn the languauge. This is coupled with the fact that fewer people are coming here to make a life and more are coming to find jobs. If you plan on making a life here, you usually want to do things legally. If you plan on making money, you usually do what costs the least out of your pocket. And despite what you might think, my gamertag doea not bias me. :)
Lusetti67's picture
Submitted by Lusetti67 on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:31
Thumbs up Darth .....................
DarthClem's picture
Submitted by DarthClem on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:43
The economic aspect of it is an interesting thing that I hadn't given much thought to. Good points.
dos's picture
Submitted by dos on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 09:51
I grew up in South Florida, so this is nothing new. It use to really bug me, but not so much anymore. We can subtitle signs and double-print assembly instructions for furniture and so on. My beef is what's spoken. If I run through the drive through at lunch to order my chicken sandwich, the joker taking my order should speak English. Same goes for Lowes. I don't want to have to start using picture cards to find the filter for my mower. And, I'm only willing to learn enough Spanish to get me by when I'm in Central America, not here in the U.S.
Gatsu's picture
Submitted by Gatsu on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 10:03
If we wanted to do it right....we all should be speaking all the native american languages. muharhar. But I do agree. English muthafucka! DO YOU SPEAK IT!??!?!
doorgunnerjgs's picture
Submitted by doorgunnerjgs on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 10:05
It bugs the crap out of me! My paternal grandfather came from Greece and paternal grandmother came from Russia. My maternal grandmother was born here but her parents came from Germany. Our daughter in law is Chinese from Malaysia, as is her mother and father. They learned English and no one put up signs in their native languages. If people don't have to learn the language of the country to which they immigrate, they won't. The government is making it too easy for individuals to retain the language of ONE segment of our population. I feel it hurts our country and it hurts the immigrants who will never properly learn English because they don't have to. And I am NOT xenophobic!
MikeTheKnife's picture
Submitted by MikeTheKnife on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 10:05
What?
FuZZ_E_BiZkitZ's picture
Submitted by FuZZ_E_BiZkitZ on Tue, 09/11/2007 - 11:04
All I have to say is that I have never had a problem ordering a meal until I was in Miami last week.

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p