Misrepresented People...

Rashanii

Shared on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:21
You know, a while back, a member by the name of Exodus ran through 2o2p spouting about how few black developers there are in video games. He also spouted lots of other rhetoric and was banned. I didn't really even think about him again until just now, when it was reported that Acclaim is going to make you pay to be a black person. Given the situation regarding this, and the Imus scandal, his words echo in my ears. Except this part now no longer seems pathetic.

It seems prophetic.

Now, before I begin, a quick quiz for you. Other than sports games, fighting games and sandbox games, how many games can you name with a black lead character? Doodi and I sat for a second without an answer, until Zikan came up with one answer. The game he mentioned was 'Beast.' Now, I've never heard of this game, but that may be because I just never really went out and looked for it, or tried it. But other than that, we were at a loss for words.

Now, as I stated on Digg.com regarding the Acclaim situation, the Cole Train from Gears of War is a supporting character, and is used essentially for comic relief. GTA: San Andreas had a black lead, but it was a sandbox game that was about gang-banging. Same with Saints Row, and even then, you didn't HAVE to be black. You could choose. Crackdown has a person of seemingly every race as a lead character. Other than that, I come up with blanks.

I even went on Google to check, and saw a post from Digg that had the same desire I did: to find the black leads in videogames. According to their report, there were, at that time, ELEVEN black leads. And out of that group, 2 were athletes: Shaquille O'Neal in Shaq-Fu and Michael Jordan in Michael Jordan: Chaos In the Windy City. Both of those were people who transcended race and thus had an audience already to sell a game platform to. One was Michael Jackson from Moonwalker, who also transcended race, and had tied the game in with his Moonwalker movie. They also listed Jade from Beyond Good and Evil, which was a great game, but I didn't think Jade was black. I was thinking Asian.

When will we ever realize that gamers don't all fit within the same box?  I am sure that the demographics of video game players show a varied base of races that play video games. Two get represented often: White and Asian, because the folks that generally make the games are either white, or asian. Bonus question: Name a black developer. I can't. I can, however, name Cliffy B., Will Wright,  David Jaffe, Shigero Miyamoto and Hideo Kojima. These were all off the top of my head, and I couldn't even ask them to make a game starring a black lead, because they don't have any reason to. Realistically, if they make a game, they are in a tough spot, because games with black leads don't seem to sell very well, unless they are of the Sandbox type. And when a game is made with a black lead, more and more often, it is the type that totally misses the point and absolutely lampoons what it was trying to build. 187 Ride or Die, anyone?

In a perfect world, a hubbub would rise up about this, and the companies would change their ways and start utilizing more diverse leads. But it won't happen. If anyone has complained, it hasn't stopped the billion dollar video game industry from growing. No matter how you complain, if you still buy it, it defeats the purpose.

But in inner cities all around the country, they are developing classes for the youth, and diversity is showing up in spades. Kids of all colors are getting an early education in video game development, and as those kids become our future developers, they will hopefully diversify the faces of lead characters. Black, White, Indian, Armenian, Asian, all will be used as lead characters in my utopia.

But they said they same thing about having a black kid or a little girl growing up to be president in the 80's.

You see how that went.

Comments

CapnHun's picture
Submitted by CapnHun on Tue, 04/17/2007 - 09:38
Well, I didn't notice the character options when we rented Crackdown; so I played the whole game as a hulking black dude, which apparently was the default character!!!
CricketCross's picture
Submitted by CricketCross on Tue, 04/17/2007 - 18:00
Just thought of a game with a black dude leading. Mech Assault. I know I'm late to the conversation here, but just thought it was worth mentioning.
Devonsangel's picture
Submitted by Devonsangel on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:25
You make a very valid point. What do you suggest we as a community can do about this? I'm open to suggestions.
eksessiv's picture
Submitted by eksessiv on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:31
I'm not usually a fan of racial debates because so often does it actually accomplish anything but more hatred. I was kind of confused this weekend when they were talking about Jackie Robinson and how so little black males play baseball now and days. I mean it seemed as if they were saying because of white people hardly any blacks play baseball on the professional level. I know there are a good bit, but it's a very small percentage compared to the whole MLG league. White people say the same stuff though when it comes to basketball because hardly any white boys are worthwhile anymore. I think a good bit of white basketball players get intimidated by a black athletes strength, speed, and tend to quit. Just my opinion because I've played with several white guys who have done that lol. So to me it's an endless revolving door debate. My take is that more black males are talented in basketball than in baseball, and vice versa for whilte males. I don't believe there is an answer for it because it can be viewed in other ways. As for the video games.... my Master Chief is like Jesus lol..... no one really knows what race he is and it's open to interpretation. That's the real reason he hasn't taken his helmet off. :)
Rashanii's picture
Submitted by Rashanii on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:33
I was listening to the Baseball debate, too, and I simply didn't play baseball because I didn't watch it. I thought it was boring. Any sport that lasts 3 hours and the final score is 2-1 isn't my cup of tea. But when I did play it, it was fun. It just didn't hold my interest.
eksessiv's picture
Submitted by eksessiv on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:35
Yea, it is pretty boring lol
eksessiv's picture
Submitted by eksessiv on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:36
No offense to JR though.... the man did some incredible stuff through some tough times. I just didn't agree with some comments the sportscasters would make. Just a matter of opinion though.
Zikan's picture
Submitted by Zikan on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:40
I was referring to the co-op character in 'Altered Beast'. But that was relying upon memories from way back in the corners of an aged and dusty mind :) My hope is that eventually the protaganist of any game will take on the personna of the person playing it. I want Sam Shepherd, Ding Chavez, the Master Chief, etc to be more like I am - and that I can do a little set up at the beginning to make my game a little more immersive. Rainbow Six:Las Vegas has this for the multiplayer/co-op, but I would like to have it in the campaign as well.
Rashanii's picture
Submitted by Rashanii on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:40
Jackie Robinson was a class act, and the sportscasters probably simply didn't know how to truly express that, so they went on a different tangent. Just a thought.
Rashanii's picture
Submitted by Rashanii on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:41
OH! Altered Beast! I loved that game. As Red said on Friday to Craig and Smokey when asked about when he tried to choke Craig in Smoke's backyard: "Oh. That was different."
Rashanii's picture
Submitted by Rashanii on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:44
I hope and pray that the camera becomes more immersive in gameplay, but in character set up as well. But nothing is worse than when the game allows you to choose race or gender, and then the game doesn't fit the different choices, like in Jade Empire, where if you chose to be the woman (I forget her name) you still kiss Grey Fox, the female ninja.
doodirock's picture
Submitted by doodirock on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:44
Oddly enough it turns out when adults really want to discuss something like race, it can be done with out fighting. Granted me and rash have been friends a while and i actually agree with him, but even still i found it quite fascinating that I couldn't think of any black gaming heroes. After reading the blog I found something very telling in the names of White/Asian developers you sounded off. People write what they know, and with the lack of black developers out there, I don't think you're going to see much African American content. The closest you get to that is characters like Coltrain from GoW and Sarge from Halo 1 and 2. It would seem that not unlike the movies, games need an infusion of culture before they can infiltrate into the mass media of gaming.
PDT816's picture
Submitted by PDT816 on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:44
Now that I think about it, I'm not sure -- but I've always assumed that Gordon Freeman from Half-Life was black.
doodirock's picture
Submitted by doodirock on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:51
@PDT816 Pretty sure he is a white guy on the cover. http://half-life2.com/
wareaglebeene1's picture
Submitted by wareaglebeene1 on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 16:57
Tiger Woods!!!! Wasn't there talk about Denzel playing Masterchief in the movie?
Rashanii's picture
Submitted by Rashanii on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 17:05
For a while, but that's just a movie. Unless they do a Samus, and pull MC's helmet off at the end of Halo 3, he isn't black. What would be cool is if you can use the camera in H3, and the end shot is you. Trademark.
CrypticCat's picture
Submitted by CrypticCat on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 18:20
The Brittish Decathlon athlete Dailey Thompson had his own game, He's black. If you want all races in games, I don't think you look hard enough. Jackie Chan is Hong-Kong Chinese. Lara Croft is representing the Anglo-saxons. Prey has a lead that's Native American. The Native American Athlete Picaboo Street had her own game. The Inuit eskimo's had their own game, but don't ask me the name of it, it was a long time ago. A lot of Japanese star in videogames. Arnold Schwarzenegger is germanic and has starred in several videogames. The Russians have starred in more videogames I can count. The Dutch had their 15 minutes of fame in Amsterdoomed... The French had a very popular manager game back in the days of the Amiga, featuring a french lead. Personally, I think that the issue of race should not be dragged onto videogames. It's just another "look we're not represented once more"-fetish. You don't hear me bitching about how Javan people (my race) are under exposed in video-games. Just for kicks, name five games with a black lead, regardless of context. Now name five games with a Javan (even though we're a Asian sub-race) lead. 'nuff said.
PabstBlueRibbon's picture
Submitted by PabstBlueRibbon on Mon, 04/16/2007 - 18:25
Interesting conversation - something I'd never really thought much of before. I would submit that there are some games that "couldn't" have a black person as a lead character. If the lead character in a game like GTA was black, the game developers would be decried as being racially insensitive I bet. No reason that a black person couldn't be a lead character in most games though.
ArminK's picture
Submitted by ArminK on Tue, 04/17/2007 - 00:33
Racial debates and topics are very touchy....but as adults we can act civil. I like the way that the games are headed now. CRACKDOWN allowing you to choose your character to best represent you. R6V for using the camera to put your mug on your character. This is probably the way it's gonna be for a while. Until developers of different races get into the positions to change things. ********************************************** That being said, NOTHING is going to change until the HATRED stops, the BLAMING stops, and understanding, compassion and love begins. Just my .02
Rashanii's picture
Submitted by Rashanii on Tue, 04/17/2007 - 00:55
I would rather have all games submit to the crackdown style, but in all honesty, when a game is really good, really really good, race just doesn't seem to matter as much.
PoltegIce's picture
Submitted by PoltegIce on Tue, 04/17/2007 - 06:22
I agree with doodi about people writing what they know, and its true. One of the things about video games is its not just a technical achievement its also an art form. Is there anything stoping these artists from creating black leads. No, except perhaps inspiration. Which is the thing, for the great games out there we need the story line and developers to be inspired. Once we start dictating to these people how they must think when they create there next great work of art it stops them from being able to think as the artist and being able to create the work of art we were hoping for. Its just a video game and I am white and if i created a video game or story or painting the main character would more likely be a white male then anything else because that is what I know. We are told by black people that we can't understand what it is like to be black, and that is true, so how can we hope to write a solid black character lead without screwing it up and making that character not believable. To create more games with different races we need more developers and artist of different race. Until then lets just keep gaming and having fun because that is what we all play video games for.

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p