Kind of torn on this one... we all know Mel Gibson is batshit insane, which could be an asset in a fight, but for pure killing power and ruthless efficiency against almost insurmountable odds, I have to give the fight to Brucie.

You got to be kidding. These two shouldn't be in the same category. John McClane...he would take out wusshead as wuss was styling his hair. Bruce could take out Mel in real life as well. "Just a fly in the ointment, Hans. The monkey in the wrench. The pain in the ass." *char can't take this so early in the morning*

I hate to give it Riggs but lets face it, he was a special forces soldier who bagged Rene Russo(when she ws smokin' hot) and that cute blonde(before they killed her and sent Riggs on a rampage).

Wow, tough call. I mean Willis is just a wrecking machine! But Gibson, as Riggs he was insane special foreces dude. His character in the Patriot was awesome and he is, "William Wallace"!!!! Gibson wins. Gibson plays a more real life badass in his movies while Bruce wins in impossible situations. Tough call, but Braveheart wins.

If Bruce was jewish then I would go with Mel, but Bruce is just a bad ass so Bruce gets my vote

I would have to go with Bruce also.

I say Bruce Willis wins! Unless It's a sword fight. ;)

Bruce Willis man FTW! 5th Element - "Anyone else wanna negotiate?"

It would have to be special forces Mel in my opinion... and when all else fails.. he goes berserker.... no solid defense against a berserker!

I say leathel weapon mel cause he was always drinkin

Heck no. Brucie all the way. Gibson plays weaker, more sentimental characters. Willis is a badass. Die Hard, Tears of the Sun, etc.

Hmmm....Lethal weapon can take the beating...but bruce has the habbit of only leaving bodies to be identified by dental records.....I have to say Bruce, more because of his role as (capt.) Muldoon in Planet Terror...he didn't fight...but he was still a serious bad ass.

Mel hands down, he's had all that special forces mumbo jumbo and is a fan of the 3 stooges, that makes him aces with me

John McClane FTW