Karate Kid, rebooted or recycled

JPNor

Shared on Mon, 07/12/2010 - 10:23

I was born in 1979, and like every other 30-year-old male in the country, The Karate Kid was one of my favorite movies growing up. Pat Morita was a legend and it has always been impossible to wax my car without saying to myself "wax on, wax off." I watched it again with my son not long ago and while he didn't seem to care for it, I enjoyed it as much as when I was six years old.

I was understandably trepidatious about watching the remake, because I didn't want to see a close friend getting viciously mutilated by modern pop culture. When the trailer was released months ago, I was completely convinced that it was going to be an awful remake. I knew I didn't want to see it, and yet I knew I would end up seeing it anyway, which I did this weekend.

I am going to step aside from man-code for a moment here and say this: I was wrong.

From the previews it's clear that they made two drastic changes - the movie takes place in China, and the central character is about 4 years younger than Ralph Macchio's Daniel in the first film. Based on these changes, I expected the entire film to stray as far as possible from the original while retaining just enough to use the marketable Karate Kid title. But they didn't. Other than the obvious changes, the writers only tweaked the original story to fit the new setting. But everything that made The Karate Kid a great cheesy 80's movie has been left intact, down to the bad-guy sensei and training montage (I half-expected to hear "You're the best, around!" but I understand the need to keep things fresh for 2010).

As much as I wanted to dislike the movie, I enjoyed it. There were a few aspects I didn't like (the "jacket off" scene, which replaces wax on and paint the fence, for one) but all in all I thought it was better than the sequels and far better than The New Karate Kid, AKA the Hillary Swank turd attempt at reviving the series.

Comments

H2Daddy's picture
Submitted by H2Daddy on Mon, 07/12/2010 - 10:31
I loved it. Just when you thought they were going to copy something exactly, they changed it a little. My kids loved it. We came home and watched the original and they didn't like it near as much as the new one. Now I have a 6 year old begging to take karate lessons.
Jedi_Kez's picture
Submitted by Jedi_Kez on Mon, 07/12/2010 - 11:21
Doesn't he learn Kung-Fu in this movie though? That's the one thing that has me confused.
JPNor's picture
Submitted by JPNor on Mon, 07/12/2010 - 11:54
Yes, and the use of Kung Fu is one of the changes they incorporated to fit the Chinese setting. As somebody who doesn't know much about the differences between Kung Fu and karate I felt the difference was minimal. Without giving away much, I really enjoyed Jackie Chan's signature fighting style during one early scene in the film.
TKBosss's picture
Submitted by TKBosss on Mon, 07/12/2010 - 13:00
Did you say the new training session was "Jack it off"??? I've been a Kung Fu master then, since I was 11!!!! :)
ChetChesterson's picture
Submitted by ChetChesterson on Thu, 07/22/2010 - 13:23
I just don't understand why they don't call it The Kung Fu Kid. As someone who does know a little about these differences between the two, to me it makes zero sense. These two styles or sytems are very different. Its like having a TV show called the "Chevy Show." and have it be about Hyndai's and not Chevrolet vehicles... I dunno. I will still probably see it though, thanks for taking the time for the recomendation.

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p