Movie ratings standards

JPNor

Shared on Sun, 04/17/2011 - 14:25

Yesterday, my wife, son and I met up with a friend who also has a 3 year old, to go to the movies. Originally we were going to see Rio but it was completely sold out so we saw Rango instead. Rango is rated PG so our friend was a bit concerned about the content for his son. My thought was that it's an animated film so the PG content was probably limited to a couple pee or fart jokes.

The movie was actually really decent. It's a western and while it's obviously a kids movie, I was really surprised by a fleeting reference to Hunter S Thompson and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. The PG rating was mostly because of one scene of dialog which contained "Sign the damn paper" and "Go to hell!" Also, a few very minor characters died and I doubt our kids fully grasped what mortality is all about.

My kid watches Family Guy so I wasn't upset about the slightly salty language in the film, however I was surprised that it made it into a kids film in the first place. I got to thinking though - a couple fart jokes and a "go to hell" are pretty much the most a PG movie can get away with today. PG movies are exclusively family films but this wasn't the case years ago. Remember Spaceballs? The movie is somewhere between 20-25 years old and was also rated PG. One scene in the film's climax, Rick Moranis says "Fuck, even in the future things don't work."

Not only was the "fuck" completely unnecessary, it still made it through the MPAA and into a PG movie. No way in hell that would fly today. I've already got two fucks in this blog - oops, make that three - so if my blog was a movie, it would probably already be rated R.

Regarding what I let my kid see on TV and movies, I'm right in the middle. I don't mind the occasional "damn" or even "shit" so I don't completely shield him from the reality of the world. However he is 3 and very impressionable so I wouldn't want him watching the South Park Movie (could you imagine him running around school yelling "DOG SHIT TACO!"?). Violence is the same way. He doesn't need to see the Saw movies but even Spongebob has silly cartoonish violence, and he seems to understand the difference between real life and fiction.

If you have young kids, where do you stand? Do you try to stick to G-rated stuff or let them see some more adult-ish content?

Comments

CrashX27's picture
Submitted by CrashX27 on Sun, 04/17/2011 - 14:58
Yeah, I remember Spaceballs, and I didn't know it was PG. I am kinda biased at what adult-like material. When it comes to sex or gore, I don't let my son watch. However, when it comes to an occasional "shit" or "damn" I can let that slide. Also violence if done in games or movies if it doesn't take pleasure in it as American Psycho or Saw. MW2 (without No Russian level) and Reach he plays, and those are M rated games. He shows he knows the difference. We also talk about the difference between real life and on screen. He doesn't swear and is understanding of what you tell him. As a single father, I am glad for this.
FadeIntoBlack's picture
Submitted by FadeIntoBlack on Sun, 04/17/2011 - 16:03
I have a 3 and a 5 year old and I am about like you describe. I don't stick to G. I even occasionally let them watch a PG-13 with me if it is something I have seen and I know all the scenes. The only thing I avoid for them is sex and real life portrayals of violence.
BalekFekete's picture
Submitted by BalekFekete on Sun, 04/17/2011 - 18:54
Rule of thumb - more or less - in our house is one rating above their actual age. PG-13 games/movies around the nine or ten year mark, and then rated M games/R movies at 14-15. So far seems to be working pretty well...
CrypticCat's picture
Submitted by CrypticCat on Sun, 04/17/2011 - 20:56
I don't have kids, but I think that there's a schism between how some regulating entities see the world and how that world actually is. Remember the original Vanishing Point movie and the girl in the desert riding a bike? In the later remake she's wearing clothes... But that's not the only thing that has changed. If you can, try and see both movies back to back. Makes you wonder what happened to American culture...

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p