Along comes Debbie Downer

JPNor

Shared on Fri, 06/06/2008 - 22:37
Just for a quick "yay me" I was promoted to a Director position at my job this week. Yay me. The promotion came with some potentially lucrative bonus incentives provided my sales team hits certain numbers. Higher numbers = higher bonuses. I'm planning on making an absurd amount of money this year.

In order to do this I don't have to re-invent the wheel but I definitely have to shine it up and pop some spinning rims on it. So I got the sales team together for a quick meeting this morning and introduced a couple new ideas. Nothing ridiculous or even that difficult, just taking several existing processes and ramping them up a bit. And everybody seemed to be on board with the new ideas.

Except for Debbie Downer.

I have one sales rep who has been with us for almost a year. She is a bit older yet inexperienced. Her numbers are there, but nothing to brag about. She does her job, but I can tell that even after a year she still doesn't quite "get" it. And I have never met anybody who is so adverse to change. Just a few months after she started, I hired an assistant to take care of some of the BS paperwork so she and the rest of the team would be able to concentrate more on making money. Regardless of the fact that my assistant was basically there to make her life easier, she still had nothing but complaints about her work. (For the record, the assistant was excellent at her job).

Back to today. Every single point of business, Debbie Downer had three counterpoints. Hand written thank you notes to accompany the new account welcome package - "some people in the department have atrocious handwriting." More trade shows - "I need more money to buy more nice clothes." Two brand new feature upgrades - "great, more product knowledge I have to memorize". These are obviously tiny hurdles but they are constant. To quote our office manager, "she bleeds negativity."

Generally I dismiss those negative concerns as non-issues and keep moving forward. But her annual review is coming up in a couple weeks - I can't wait to see her reaction when I score her on the "attitude" section.

Debbie Downer works all different kinds of jobs, everywhere in the world. Does she also work next to you? How do you handle it?

Comments

JPNor's picture
Submitted by JPNor on Mon, 06/09/2008 - 12:38
You've never gotten a thank you note for spending thousands of dollars on something?
corbin_dallas's picture
Submitted by corbin_dallas on Sat, 06/07/2008 - 07:22
There's the door...if you're not a "team player" then find somewhere else to work. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but in the business world negativity is the kiss of death. If she's negative in the office, how does she act with a client??
Science's picture
Submitted by Science on Sat, 06/07/2008 - 11:31
I would challenge you to view her as an analytical and critical thinker rather than someone with a "negative" attitude. On a team it's good to have someone who can point out the possible pitfalls of new ideas. That doesn't mean that it's OK for her to shit in everyones Cheerios all the time either. As a supervisor, I try to help people with this skill learn how to censor themselves appropriately. Let some of the minor problems go unspoken. Also, try to help her learn to phrase things better. For instance instead of saying "great, more product knowledge I have to memorize." say something like, "Product upgrades sound great, but that also means we'll all have to increase our product knowledge. Are we all OK with that?" The thing to keep in mind is that she probably sees her critical thought as one of her greatest strengths, if you jump all over her for having a "bad attitude" her likely response will be bitterness, distrust, and poor performance. If you can identify and appreciate her strength, then help her develop it so that it works to the best advantage of the team you will get more out of her than you ever thought possible. That's my $0.02
wilderz's picture
Submitted by wilderz on Tue, 06/10/2008 - 08:08
Depending on how many customers you have, it may be time consuming. Can the Assistant make them up, and then have your sales staff distribute them? At one of my previous jobs, we just created a nice graphic in photoshop, typed a quick 'thank-you' in a nice font, and printed off a bunch of those suckers. I think we need to have a meeting regarding this meeting! :^)
VenomRudman's picture
Submitted by VenomRudman on Sun, 06/08/2008 - 01:00
Just because people don't agree with your brilliant new ideas doesn't mean they are being negative. Maybe your ideas suck. Hand written notes? WTF?

Join our Universe

Connect with 2o2p